Jio vs Airtel vs Vodafone Idea - Subscriber Numbers upto July'19

Every month we have been reading reports of Reliance Jio adding a few million subscribers and Airtel + Vodafone Idea losing a few million of theirs. July'19 is no different. Reliance Jio maintained it's subscribers momentum with addition of another 8.5 million subscribers in July'19, taking it's total to almost 340 million. Vodafone Idea lost a smaller number of users compared to the previous 2 months. It's total subscriber base now stands at 380 million, down by 3.4 million. Airtel has now included Tata Tele's subscribers in it's count. Tata Tele had about 11.5 million subscribers in June'19. But Airtel+Tata Tele's subscriber count has jumped from 320.3 million in June'19 to 328.5 million in July'19. That means Airtel also lost nearly 3.2 million subscribers during July'19.

All the three operators have seen their VLR % erode during July'19. Starting with Airtel, it's own VLR % at the end of June'19 was 98.5%, which dropped to 94.95% in July'19. This is mainly due to addition of Tata Tele's subscribers in it's total count. Most of these Tata Tele's subscribers were already using Airtel's network on Roaming. Hence this had helped boost Airtel's VLR % for the previous few months, as can be seen from the table alongside. Airtel's VLR base has dropped from 315.5 million to 311.9 million, i.e. a drop of 3.6 million active users. The same at the end of January'19 was 331.2 million. That means Airtel has lost close to 16 million active users during these 6 months.

Looking at Vodafone Idea, it is already tainted to be the worst performing Telecom operator in terms of subscriber & revenue growth in the recent months. The effects of large-scale Network Integration activity across several circles has had a severe impact on Vodafone Idea's active subscribers count post March'19. At the end of March'19, Vodafone Idea's Total subscribers were 395 million, which is now down to 380 million, i.e. a loss of just 15 million users in 4 months time. Nothing alarming. But during the same period, it's VLR % has dropped from 93.3% to 81.9%, in a staggered manner. This means it's active subscriber count has dropped from 368 million to 311 million over those 4 months, i.e. a loss of 57 million, which is large figure. An average of over 14 million a month!! This is substantially more than what Jio is adding every month.

Over the last month or so, we have seen several announcements from Vodafone Idea about launch of TurboNet 4G services in more & more cities across the country. TurboNet 4G is the brand they have adopted for announcing the launch of Integrated network for Vodafone & Idea combined. TurboNet 4G also represents the launch of a network which is expected to offer wider coverage & much larger capacity than before, with the help of the largest spectrum pool amongst all operators in India. This should help improve adoption of 4G services amongst Vodafone & Idea users and also attract users from rival networks. We may not see much of it's effect in August numbers, but I am sure we will start seeing a boost in numbers for Vodafone Idea from September'19 onwards. Apart from launch of TurboNet 4G, Vodafone Idea has also introduced lower denomination recharge options for users to remain active on the network.

Coming to Reliance Jio, it's monthly subscriber addition numbers have been very consistent. It seems as if the company is despatching only a limited number of simcards / Jio Phones every month. For the 6 months between January to July'19, Jio's Total subscriber base went up from 289 million to 340 million, i.e. 51 million new additions translating into 8.5 million every month. That is precisely the number they are adding every month. Even their VLR % is steady around the 83-84% mark. Looks like everything is working in a very measured fashion. Sometimes even raises a doubt in my mind whether these are genuine numbers or manufactured ones.

Airtel & Vodafone Idea are now neck-to-neck in terms of active subscribers. It will be an interesting race from September'19 onwards. Airtel might inch ahead in August as Vodafone Idea's TurboNet 4G marketing started only in the latter half of August. In about 4 to 5 months time, Jio will close the gap between it's Active base numbers and the other two, which currently stands at about 29 million. And most probably Jio will just zoom past both of them. Both Airtel & Vodafone Idea are unlikely to offer something like the Jio Phone, which is what is pulling major numbers for Reliance Jio since the last couple of years. Both Airtel & Vodafone Idea will prefer to expand their 4G network coverage to get closer to that offered by Jio currently and target the Smartphone users to upgrade to 4G or pull a few dis-satisfied users from Jio or BSNL.

That brings us to the comparison of Wireless Broadband numbers of the 3 operators. Jio's entire subscriber base is counted as Broadband user base as it's 4G-only network. In case of both Airtel & Vodafone Idea, it comprises of 4G and 3G subscribers. The 3G subscriber base for both operators is rapidly falling. Both have less than 25 million 3G users on their Networks as of July'19. By the end of this year, both operators are expected to shut down 3G networks as the same spectrum can be used to add to their 4G capacity. So all these 40 to 50 million 3G users will be forced to upgrade their handsets and start availing 4G services over the next 3 to 6 months.

Airtel's Wireless Broadband user base has been steadily increasing over the last 6 months. It went from 110 million in January'19 to over 121 million in July'19, i.e. at a pace of almost 2 million a month. On the other hand, Vodafone Idea had a tough time trying to maintain it's wireless broadband user numbers between February'19 to May'19, when it lost about 1.25 million users. It has seen some increase for the last 2 months of June & July'19. I am pretty sure that this will pick up pace from September'19 onwards & we could see Vodafone Idea adding 2 million+ Wireless Broadband users every month. This race between Airtel and Vodafone Idea will get very interesting by the end of 2019. I am excited to see which one of the two proves to be a bigger challenger to Jio in the year 2020. So far we all know that Airtel has performed better than Vodafone Idea. But there are reasons for the same. As Vodafone Idea starts pushing it's upgraded network services through formal advertisement channels, we should see the company numbers start improving.

Bharti Airtel Q3 Numbers - Finer Details

I was anxiously waiting to have a look at Bharti Airtel's Q3 numbers last evening as this is the first quarterly result to have full impact of Reliance Jio's launch momentum. The numbers for Q2 only had partial impact due to Jio. And the numbers have turned out to be exactly as per my expectations. Ever since Jio's launch on 5th Sept'16, I had estimated a drop of between 5 to 10% in Revenues for both Bharti Airtel & Idea Cellular, when compared to their numbers for June'16 quarter. As it turned out, Bharti Airtel's Revenues from India Mobile services business has dropped just over 8% from Rs.15,053 crores to Rs.13,837 crores. Bharti Airtel's Consolidated Total Income is also down by 8.5% during the same period at Rs.23,416 crores. The drop in Non-India Revenues is mainly due to exit/mergers from a few markets in Africa and South-East Asia. Bharti Airtel's Non-Mobile India revenues posted some decent growth, which helped reduce the impact due to drop in Data as well as Voice Revenues from it's India Mobile business.

Getting to analysing the finer details of Traffic & Financial numbers of Bharti Airtel for October to December'16 quarter, it is very important to note that the impact on revenue flow for the operator due to Reliance Jio must not have been uniform for each of the 3 months. The impact must have been the smallest in October and the largest in December. Reliance Jio had about 16 million users at the start of the quarter, while it is estimated to have ended the quarter with about 70 million users. That means the 4G competitor added an average of about 18 million users every month. Also if we look at the overall user experience of Reliance Jio's services, it was pretty bad in most parts of the country during the first half of the quarter, with over 75% of the Voice Calls attempted from Jio numbers to non-Jio numbers failing to connect. Even the Data speeds on Jio's 4G network was quite patchy & inconsistent due to huge number of users abusing the network with full utilisation of FUP limits. Hence during the first half of the quarter, most Jio users must have required to recharge & use their primary mobile numbers, which must have been from one of the other operators (including Airtel). The user experience on Reliance Jio's network improved dramatically from the middle of November'16, when most Voice Calls to non-Jio numbers were getting connected on first or second attempt. Even the Data speeds became more consistent, though it was not as fast as expected, but fairly use-able. Hence the latter half of the Oct-Dec'16 quarter is when the older operators must have suffered the most slowdown in revenue flow due to Reliance Jio's Free services. Not just Data usage, but a substantial portion of Voice usage too must have shifted to Jio.

Have a look at the chart alongside, which shows the progress made by Bharti Airtel's Consolidated Quarterly Total Income since the December'13 quarter onwards. Notice the sharp slide after hitting a peak value of just over Rs.25,500 crores in June'16. The figure for December'16 quarter is even lower than that for June'15 quarter. That means the gains made by Bharti Airtel over 4 or 5 quarters upto June'16, have been wiped out in just 2 quarters. And things are expected to get even more worse for March'17 quarter as Reliance Jio's Free services have been extended till the end of March'17. At the current pace of revenue erosion, I am expecting Bharti Airtel's Total Income to fall to something around Rs.22,000 crores, if not lower, for the March'17 quarter. Airtel has managed to limit the damage to it's EBITDA via some smart Cost-reduction measures during the Dec'16 quarter. But there may not be too many cost-cutting avenues left as it cannot compromise much on the quality of service aspect. This erosion in revenues will stop only when Reliance Jio starts charging for it's services and we get to see some fair tariff-based & quality-based competition amongst all players.

Coming to Users & Usage statistics, this is probably for the first time since Wireless Broadband services over 3G/4G networks were launched, when Bharti Airtel has reported a Q-o-Q drop in number of 3G/4G users as well as the amount of GBs carried by it's network during the

quarter. The volume of GBs consumed by Airtel's customers was growing at a compounded double-digit Q-o-Q Growth rate until September'16. But it has seen a Drop of 3.5% during December'16. This drop in Volume, coupled with another 10.5% Q-o-Q drop in Rate per MB, meant that Bharti Airtel's Revenues from Wireless Data services have taken a hit of about 14% Q-o-Q. Bharti Airtel's Average Rate per MB has now dropped to just under 18 paise, which translates to about Rs.180 per GB. We all know that the Average Rates for most of the heavy Data consumers of almost all operators have now dropped to something around Rs.100 per GB or even lower. Hence I won't be surprised if Bharti Airtel reports an average Rate of around 12 to 14 paise per MB for the March'17 quarter. To compensate for this 25 to 30% drop in average realisation per MB, the volume needs to increase by a similar pace. But it certainly looks difficult in the current scenario and hence we can expect easily another 15 to 20% Q-o-Q drop (if not more) in Revenues from Wireless Data services for Bharti Airtel's India business for March'17 quarter.

Going by the way we have seen improvement in Reliance Jio's user experience since the start of the new calendar year, especially on the Data services front, it is very unlikely that a user of Reliance Jio will pay anything to other operators for availing Data services, atleast till the end of March'17. Most of the owners of 4G Smartphones across the country have already taken a Reliance Jio Sim, atleast as a secondary connection. There won't be much revenue coming to any of the incumbent operators for availing Data services. Operators like Airtel/Vodafone/Idea have been trying their best to entice buyers of new 4G Smartphones with Special Offers of something like 10 GB 4G-Data for the price of 1 GB or the latest offer from Airtel, which offers additional 3 GB 4G-Data every month for a period of 12 months on certain recharge plans, for users upgrading to 4G Smartphones until the end of February'17. All such efforts are being made with an aim to increase usage on their networks and maintain some decent level of ARPU from active users. 

At the same time, these older operators are aggressively trying to attract 2G & 3G users of smaller operators with competitive Voice &

Data tariffs. With intensifying competition from larger rivals with much wider network coverage & matching tariffs, survival will get more & more difficult for smaller operators. I think the shift is already happening at a healthy pace. But there is bad news for the incumbents here as well. There are rumours floating around that Reliance Jio is planning to launch 4G-VoLTE enabled feature phones at aggressive price points of under Rs.1500/-. This coupled with Unlimited All-India Calling & Roaming plans, Reliance Jio could start grabbing market share even in the feature-phone users space, which is still pretty large in our country. I am expecting the launch of the 4G-VoLTE enabled feature phones to align with the point when Reliance Jio starts charging for it's services. This launch will only mean more trouble for incumbents and other smaller operators.

For the December'16 quarter, Bharti Airtel did manage to post some decent growth in Voice minutes. But this growth was powered by the surge in Incoming Calls from Jio network. This resulted in lowering of average realisation rate per min more than the increase in Volume, hence resulting in a small drop in revenues from Voice services as well. Until now most Jio users are using their Jio Sim as a secondary connection. As and when large number of users start porting their primary numbers to Jio network, the Voice service revenues for all existing operators will start getting impacted even more. The Q3-FY'17 results for Bharti Airtel have now given us a fairly good idea of the kind of pain all operators are expected to go through over the next few quarters. Yes, things are expected to remain painful for not just one or two quarters, but for atleast 4 to 6 quarters. We can expect things to stabilise & bottom out Bharti Airtel & others, sometime by the end of 2017 and start improving from first half of 2018 onwards. All eyes are now on Idea Cellular's Q3 numbers. Story is expected to be similar for India's No.3 operator. But it doesn't have the cushion of Non-Mobile services that Bharti Airtel has. Hence Idea Cellular will most probably report slightly larger drops.

Reliance Industries Ltd. - Segmentwise Numbers Progress

India's No.1 company in terms of Annual Net Profits as well as Market Capitalisation, Reliance Industries Ltd., announced it's Q3-FY'17 numbers yesterday. The numbers were fairly good & mostly in line with expectations mentioned by most analysts. In my report here I will focus on things which are generally not mentioned anywhere else. I like to study the progress of a company on a Trailing-Twelve-Months (T-T-M) basis. The study of T-T-M numbers over a period of last 2 or 3 years gives us a fairly good idea of the company's performance trend.

Before we get to the Segment-wise Numbers, first lets quickly have a look at some of the key Consolidated numbers for Reliance Industries Ltd. The following charts are showing the T-T-M progress of RIL's Total Income, EBITDA, Interest Cost & Net Profit figures starting from the period ending December'13 upto period ending December'16. Have a look at the charts:

After hitting a peak of about Rs.4,50,000 crores in June'14, RIL's T-T-M Total Income figure saw a sharp slide and finally bottomed out at about Rs.2,86,000 crores in June'16. There was nothing wrong with the company's performance during this period. The sharp drop in Total Income was purely due to sharp drop in Product prices. 90% of RIL's turnover is contributed by Refining, Petrochemicals and Oil&Gas Production businesses, all of which derive it's product prices from Crude Oil. The Crude Oil prices had started sliding during the 2nd half of the year 2014 and bottomed out sometime in the early part of year 2016. With the Crude Oil prices slowly moving up over the last couple of quarters, we can already see RIL's T-T-M Total Income figure also reflecting the trend. RIL's T-T-M EBITDA chart gives us a better idea of the kind of performance RIL has managed even during the falling product prices regime. While RIL's Total Income started sliding after June'14, it's EBITDA was quite steady around the Rs.45,000 crores mark till September'15, which means the company was able to protect it's profits comfortably even when product prices were falling as it managed it's raw material cycle too very well.

After September'15, RIL has seen it's EBITDA margins genuinely expand from improvement in process efficiencies at both it's Refining as well as Petrochemicals units. Reliance Industries Ltd. has been undertaking a massive CAPEX program for it's Petrochemicals complex, which is expected to help the company improve it's cost efficiency substantially, which will in turn help the company expand it's profit margins. The commissioning of the CAPEX program has started a few weeks ago & will be done in stages over the next few months. We should start seeing it's impact on the company's results from Q4-FY'17 onwards. On one side we will see RIL's EBITDA from it's primary businesses of Refining & PetChem expand over the next few quarters, but we should also be mindful of the fact that RIL's single largest CAPEX program in it's entire history, Reliance Jio Infocom Ltd, is also expected to start billing it's customers from Q1-FY'18. The commissioning of Reliance Jio Infocom Ltd. is expected to be EBITDA negative for the initial year or two. Hence there is a strong likelihood of RIL reporting a Y-o-Y drop in Consolidated EBITDA for a few quarters, starting from Q1-FY'18. Apart from the drop in EBITDA, RIL will also see it's Interest Cost and Depreciation provisioning shoot up substantially from current levels, which might result in wiping out of most of it's Net Profit, atleast for a few quarters. The first couple of quarters of RJIL's commissioning will be the worst for RIL's financial numbers, but things will progressively improve at a rapid pace after that.

Segment-wise Revenue Performance: Currently RIL reports it's results distributed over 5 segments: Refining, Petro-Chemicals, Oil & Gas, Retail and Others (which includes it's Media & Broadband businesses). Once RJIL (Jio 4G) starts billing it's customers, it will form a separate segment.

Let's look at T-T-M progress of RIL's 4 basic operating segments (excluding Others). RIL's primary businesses of Refining & Petrochemicals continue to contribute nearly 90% to the company's Revenues and are responsible for the entire Net Profits. In fact the company is using strong Cash Flows from these businesses to help support & fund it's investments into newer avenues like Media & Telecom.
Refining business of RIL has seen it's T-T-M revenues falling from a peak level of little over Rs.4,00,000 crores to around Rs.2,25,000 crores levels (a drop of about 45% from the peak), which has been steady since the last 3 quarters. Despite the Q-o-Q rise in Crude Oil prices over the last couple of quarters, we are yet to see a noticeable uptick in RIL's T-T-M numbers, mainly because there has not been any significant change in Y-o-Y prices of Crude Oil. Jan-Mar'16 was the quarter when Crude Oil prices had hit the lowest levels in recent years of less than $30 per barrel (though for a short duration only). Hence if Crude Oil prices stay at current levels of $50+ levels during this current quarter, we could see RIL post healthy Y-o-Y growth in Revenues from it's Refining business.
The Petrochemicals business of RIL has done far better than it's Refining business. The T-T-M revenues from RIL's Petrochemicals business dropped just about 20% from it's peak values, bottomed out by the end of June'16 quarter and has already started posting healthy Y-o-Y growth, which is clearly noticeable in the charts. With completion of major CAPEX investments into the Petrochemicals business and it's commissioning, we could see momentum building up further in RIL's Petrochemicals revenues and even bigger momentum in it's profits from these units.
The Oil & Gas production business has faced an even bigger brunt of the fall in Crude Oil prices as it suffered from not just price crash, but even the production at several of the units had to be curtailed temporarily as it because economically unviable to produce when prices were under $45 per barrel. Over the last few months, the Crude Oil price has remained above the $45 levels quite consistently with not much of wild swings as before. Hence many of the Shale Gas units, which had shut production last year, could start producing again now. Any recovery in Revenue levels for RIL from this business will depend on Crude price stability above a certain level and the way the production is ramped up at producing fields.
The Retail business of RIL was growing it's T-T-M Revenues at a steady pace of around 4% Q-o-Q until March'16. This was a healthy growth rate given the extensive competition in this field from not just other Retail chains and standalone stores, but also from the e-commerce biggies. Over the last 3 quarters RIL's Retail business has been posting much faster growth in Revenues, thanks to increased footfalls in it's stores, especially the Reliance Digital stores for Jio Sim cards and LYF devices. Reliance Retail has also started supplying it's devices to other standalone mobile stores in thousands of smaller towns since about June-July'16. RIL's Retail business is now very close to hitting the Rs.30,000 crores T-T-M turnover mark and going by the healthy expected growth pace, we could very well see it hitting the Rs.40,000 crores turnover mark anytime over the next 3 to 5 quarters.

Segment-wise Profit (EBIT) Performance: The charts representing T-T-M Profit (Earnings Before Interest & Tax) for RIL's different segments

show quite different patterns, especially for Refining & Petrochemicals businesses. RIL's Refining business has seen a sharp improvement in it's T-T-M Profits from levels of about Rs.15,000 crores in December'14 to levels of just over Rs.25,000 crores since the last couple of quarters. The trend of increasing profits seems to have come to a halt now as we can see a plateau formation since the last 3 quarters, which has somewhat coincided with trend reversal in Crude Prices. I think it will be an achievement even if RIL manages to keep it's T-T-M Profits from Refining business steady at current levels even during the period when Crude prices are rising. The Refining business is the main Cash Generator for RIL and hence even if it manages to keep the figure steady at around current levels, it will be a very big positive for the company overall.
The T-T-M Profits from Petrochemicals business of RIL started reporting smart growth from the June'15 quarter onwards. The Profit number has already seen a near 50% increase over the last 7 quarters. The trend of increasing Profits from Petrochemicals business is expected to continue at a healthy pace, given the fact that the CAPEX commissioning is underway. I am expecting RIL's profits from Petrochemicals business to grow atleast another 50% from current levels over the next 3 to 5 quarters.
The T-T-M Profit figures for RIL's Oil & Gas Production business only reflect the disastrous period it has faced over the last 6 to 8 quarters due to falling Crude Prices. In fact curtailment of Production has helped limit the losses to not-so-significant levels. I think we will a trend reversal in these figures after another one or two quarters, provided that the Crude Prices remain steady at current levels of improve further.
RIL's Retail business is doing pretty well on the Profit front too, especially over the last 3 quarters. The T-T-M Profit figure from the Retail business currently stands at about Rs.670 crores. Given the strong growth momentum, I think it will hit the Rs.1000 crores mark in the next 3 quarters for sure. And there is scope for continued long term double-digit Y-o-Y Growth in this business even after that.


Telecom Venture: Reliance Jio Infocom Ltd ( RJIL )has been in the news on a regular basis and it's 'Jio' branded 4G services have been in limelight since Aug-Sept'16. As per latest reports, RJIL has already enrolled over 72 million users for it's 4G services across the country and the number is expected to be around 90 to 100 million by the end of March'17. The primary reason for such a large number of users enrolling for Jio 4G services within a span of just a few months is that it is currently offered FREE. As per latest announcement, the service is expected to remain FREE till 31st March'17. This means that during this period, eventhough RJIL incurs all the operational costs of keeping the network online and continue expanding the coverage & capacity, it will not earn any revenue till the end of the FREE period. Starting from 1st January'17, users of Jio 4G service are entitled to 1 GB of Data at 4G speed per day, after which the speed is restricted to 128 kbps. The users have the option to unlock 4G speed again by recharging their account with Rs.51 (for 1 GB data) or Rs.301 (for 6 GB data). The revenues from these recharge options is expected to be negligible till 31st March'17.

As per my estimate, RJIL's Operating Costs (including Interconnect Cost) to keep the Network online must be easily in the region of Rs.1500 to 2000 crores per month, if not more. That means a sum of around Rs.4500 to 6000 crores per quarter is being spent, without earning any revenue from the 4G service being offered. Remember that the expenditure amount mentioned above excludes the Interest Cost on the Debt raised for this venture. All these Expenditures & Interest Costs are currently being Capitalised and will start getting amortised once RJIL's numbers start getting Consolidated into RIL's Profit & Loss account. All this is expected to hurt RIL's Consolidated numbers very badly once it starts recognising RJIL's numbers. The first couple of quarters will be the worst when RJIL's Net Loss could potentially wipe out RIL's Net Profit from other business segments. Things are expected to steadily improve after that, but the pace of improvement will certainly depend on competitive pressures in the industry. The telecom competitors will also react to whatever tariff plans RJIL finally comes up with and hence it will take not just aggressive tariff plans, but also aggressive marketing to get the revenue momentum going. As per my rough estimates, RJIL needs a minimum Average Revenue Per User (ARPU) per month of Rs.300 from about 100 million Paying-Customers to be able to close to covering all it's Operating Costs and Interest Costs.

In the mean time, this extended FREE service period of RJIL is forcing consolidation within the Industry at a rapid pace. Some smaller operators have sold off their auction-purchased 4G-capable spectrum to larger operators. A few other smaller operators are trying to merge together & form a larger force in the market. A couple of other smaller players are still confused on what to do, but their weak financial position will also force them to either merge themselves with a larger operator or shut-down operations in loss making circles & focus on select strong circles. All this consolidation or shut-downs are expected to benefit all the larger operators over the medium to long term, including RJIL. Even though rumours are currently flying that RJIL is likely to extend it's existing offer in slightly altered form beyond 31st March'17, I believe that the more RJIL delays charging it's customers for service, the more damage it is causing to it's image as well as finances. It is quite obvious that RJIL is currently pushing for certain 'Records' in terms of customer enrollments and Network Usage statistics, etc. At the same time it is trying to cause maximum damage to competition. RJIL is able to do all this only because of it's Cash-rich parent's backing. But Regulatory & Financial sense will ultimately prevail and hopefully we should see Fair competition soon.